9. Personal use of genetically engineered products


9.1 How Many People Would Use Genetically Engineered Products?
9.2 Patterns of Use
9.3 Who Would Use Genetically Engineered Products?
9.4 Summary: Use of Genetically Modified Products


9.1 How Many People Would Use Genetically Engineered Products?

The ISSS survey asked whether people would themselves use genetically engineered products:



4 ... a. Would you like to try eating this new 
[genetically modified] tomato?

                Yes, definitely                 17              
                Yes, probably                   44              
                Mixed feelings; yes and no      16              
                No, probably not                17              
               No, definitely not               7                                                      
                                                ---                                                     
                                               100% (mean= 62


6. How do you feel about using genetically engineered products yourself...

a. Would you wear clothes made from genetically engineered cotton?              

                Yes, definitely                 25              
                Yes, probably                   52              
               Mixed feelings; yes and no      18              
                No, probably not                 4              
                No, definitely not               1                                                      
                                                ---                                                     
                                                100% (mean= 74)

b. Would you eat leaner, healthier pork developed by genetic engineering?               

                Yes, definitely                 14              
                Yes, probably                   42              
               Mixed feelings; yes and no      24              
               No, probably not                14              
                No, definitely not               6                                                      
                                                ---                                                     
                                                100% (mean= 61)

c. Eat healthier cooking oil or margarine made by genetic engineering?          



               Yes, definitely                 18              
                Yes, probably                   48              
               Mixed feelings; yes and no      22              
               No, probably not                 9              
                No, definitely not               3                                                      
                                                      ---                                                     
                                                100% (mean= 67)


Most people would like to try eating genetically engineered tomatoes: 17% definitely yes and 44% probably yes. Some 16% are undecided, 17% think probably not and 7% definitely not. So in all, a majority of Australians would eat them, 61% yes, 16% are undecided, and 24% would not. A plurality of Canadians would also eat them (44% yes, 22% undecided, 32% no: Optima 1994: 15).

The public is quite comfortable about wearing clothes made from genetically engineered cotton. 25% would definitely wear them and a further 52% would probably wear them -- in all, an overwhelming majority. 18% have mixed feelings. Only 4% would probably not wear them and 1% definitely not. This gives a mean approval score of 74 points out of 100.

Most people would eat genetically engineered lean pork. 14% definitely would and 42% probably would, in all a modest majority. 22% are undecided and 14% probably would not eat it and 6% definitely not eat it (a few of these may be people who don't eat any kind of pork). In all, this gives genetically engineered pork 61 points out of 100.

The public is pretty comfortable with genetically engineered cooking oil or margarine. 18% would definitely use it and 48% probably would, in all a strong majority. 22% are undecided, 9% would probably not use it, and 3% would definitely not use it.

9.2 Patterns of Use

People who would eat genetically engineered pork are very likely to use genetically engineered cooking oil as well, and vice versa. Wearing clothes from genetically engineered cotton is somewhat different from these. So it is appropriate to distinguish two aspects of use:

[Definition] Use of Genetically Engineered Food = mean( Eat G-E pork, use G-E cooking oil )

[Definition] Use Genetically Engineered Cotton = Single item: Wear clothes from G-E cotton )

9.3 Who Would Use Genetically Engineered Products?

9.3.1 Genetically Engineered Foods

Men are a little more likely than women to eat genetically engineered foods (beta=.11). Otherwise there are few differences between social or demographic groups.

Knowledge matters: those who know more about genetic engineering are substantially more likely to be willing to eat genetically engineered foods (beta=.12).

Holding a scientific world-view also makes one more likely to eat genetically modified foods (beta=.12).

People who are worried about the risks of genetically engineered products are much less likely to be willing to use them themselves (beta=-.27). Those who worry about fluorides in the drinking water are also dubious about genetically engineered food (beta=-.13.

Finally, those who support scientific research on agriculture in general are themselves more willing to eat genetically engineered foods (beta=.29).

9.3.2 Clothes from Genetically Engineered Cotton

Men are neither more nor less willing than women to wear clothes from genetically engineered cotton. The old are not as keen as the young (beta=-.10) but otherwise there are no noticeable differences between demographic or social groups.

Knowledge and a scientific world-view are conducive to using genetically engineered cotton.

People who are worried about the risks of genetically engineered products are somewhat less keen on genetically engineered cotton (beta=-.-19), as are those who worry about fluorides in the drinking water (beta=-.11).

Finally, people who support scientific research on agriculture in general are a little keener on genetically engineered cotton (beta=.14), as are those keen on medical research (beta=.09).

9.4 Summary: Use of Genetically Modified Products

The vast majority of Australians would wear clothes made from genetically engineered cotton (77%). The rest are mostly undecided (18%), with only 5% definitely unwilling. Clear majorities would eat genetically engineered cooking oil (60%), tomatoes (61%), and pork (56%) with most of the rest undecided rather than definitely unwilling.

Most willing to use genetically engineered products are those who generally support scientific research on agriculture, those less worried about the risks of genetic engineering, those more knowledgeable about it, and those who have a scientific rather than religious world-view.

 


To top of page
To next Chapter
Table of Contents