WwA: Worldwide Attitudes
Version 1.3
REFEREE'S REPORT
Title of manuscript:
Evaluation:
| 1. Is the article interesting -- would you choose to read it yourself? | Yes!! Yes ?? No No!! |
|
| 2. Does it use a good data set? | Yes!! Yes ?? No No!! |
|
| 3. Is the analysis sound? | Yes!! Yes ?? No No!! |
|
| 4. Are the results novel? | Yes!! Yes ?? No No!! |
|
| 5. Are revisions required? | Yes!! Yes ?? No No!! |
|
| 6. All in all, do you recommend publishing? | Definitely publish Probably publish Revise & resubmit Reject |
Confidential comments for the editor:
Referee's Name:
Comments for the Author
| Is the article well organized? | Yes!! Yes ?? No No!! |
|
| Suggestions: | ||
| Are changes needed in the analysis? | Yes!! Yes ?? No No!! |
|
| Suggestions: | ||
| Does anything in the existing literature need consideration? | Yes!! Yes ?? No No!! |
|
| What? | ||
| Anything else? | ||